In the case of district heating systems, the distribution system can be flown rapidly and inexpensively to provide thermal data for asset management planning and predictive maintenance (PdM).  As a result of finding and repairing leaks in the steam system, energy usage can be reduced with all the related benefits.

Leaks and insulation failure in overhead steam lines and underground steam lines (direct-bury lines and in steam tunnels), can result in less than optimal energy efficiency, especially when the steam leaks and line heat losses (see Figure 1), are undetected, inaccessible or difficult to find given the vast acreage at some facilities.  The longer that a steam leak or excessive heat loss on a line and/or undetected draining of fluids (see Figure 2) goes undetected; the greater the energy loss, the more make-up chemicals have to be added and the more potential there is for negative environmental impact.



Understanding Aerial Infrared

Aerial infrared can help monitor the steam distribution system so that those charged with the task, can better manage the assets.  Checking the boilers, lines and steam traps inside buildings and inside steam tunnels are jobs best accomplished on the ground, but the distribution and condensate return lines are best surveyed from the air.  Thermal contrast between active lines and the surrounding ground are usually good, depending on the depth of the line, temperature, flow and the materials covering the lines.  The entire system can be flown, a mosaic thermal image produced and the areas with suspected problems can be pinpointed and documented. On-ground, hand-held IR surveys on all but very small areas within a system are time-consuming, labor intensive and produce small field of vision imagery and/or paint on the ground.  Owing to recent developments in infrared technology and the availability of high thermal sensitivity/high spatial resolution (large format) thermal imaging systems mounted on an aerial platform, the on-ground survey has become outdated.

The methodology for taking aerial infrared thermographs is similar in many ways to taking aerial photographs.  To collect the data, the aircraft flies over a given area with a camera mounted to the airframe and oriented looking straight-down to the ground (NADIR).  The imagery is stored on a computer hard drive and later post-processed.  Where aerial infrared thermography differs from aerial visible photography is the time of day when the survey occurs and the wavelength of the imagery that the detector collects.  IR thermography of ground objects is performed at night.  Thermography reveals sources of heat and the relative differences in heat from one object to another.

Steam Leak Infrared Surveying

Steam and condensate return lines are almost always readily visible with infrared imaging, even when no notable problems exist.  This is due to the fact that no matter how good the insulation, there is always heat loss from the lines which makes its way to the surface.  Problem areas are generally quite evident, having brighter infrared signatures (see Figure 3) that exceed the norm.


Steam line faults normally appear as an overheated line or as a large hotspot in the form of a bulge or balloon along the line.  Overheated lines often occur when the steam line is located in a conduit or tunnel.  If there is a leak in the line, it will heat up the conduit with escaping steam.  If a steam line is buried directly in the ground with an insulating jacket, a leak will usually saturate the insulation, rendering it largely ineffective and begin to transfer heat into the ground around the leak, producing the classic bulge or balloon-like hot area straddling the line.

Some leaks show up as an overheated manhole or vault cover.  Manholes or vaults that contain steam system control apparatus which are leaking, will often heat the covers to warmer than normal temperatures.  Unless these leaks are severe enough to significantly raise the manhole temperature above their normally slightly elevated temperatures, these leaks can be difficult to identify.  In fact, steam line infrared imagery can be a little misleading, unless one understands and interprets the relative brightness and temperature of a given line correctly.  For instance, a steam line that is the same temperature from one end to the other that passes under different surfaces and materials can exhibit a variety of real and perceived temperature variations.  Five different apparent temperatures will result from the same temperature line that runs under a grass-covered field, an asphalt roadway, a concrete loading dock, a gravel-covered parking lot and a bare earth pathway.

Thermal Mapping, Ortho-Rectification and Post-Processing

Using a non fixed-mounted high-resolution thermal imager to survey a couple of buildings or a few thousand feet of underground lines can be done by flying over and locating the target(s) in the imagery, saving the data and putting it together into a report.  This works for very small areas, but it is not possible to make precise thermal maps of a whole complex, campus, military base or city (see Figures 4) without ortho-rectification of the imagery.  In order to produce ortho-rectified thermal maps, much more information must be gathered and tagged to the IR imagery.  During the flight, the aircraft flies straight, smooth lines on a pre-planned grid, allowing overlap and sidelap of the imagery.  The IR operator manages the sensor data-acquisition following a structured checklist for orderly data file management.  The imagery must be collected with a precise direct-digital timing system, a 3-axis ring-laser-gyro and an inertial navigation system (INS), which is tightly-coupled to a real-time differential GPS satellite positioning system that provides x, y, z positioning of the sensor at all times.


After data is collected, the digital infrared imagery is processed into a series of ortho-rectified image tiles, which are then stitched together to create a giant mosaic image.  A computer system puts all this information together using a digital elevation model (DEM) of the scene that consists of a uniform grid of point elevation values and the position and orientation of the camera with respect to a three-dimensional coordinate system output.  The result is presented as a high-resolution thermal image in the form of a geo-TIFF (see Figure 5), which is compatible with any GIS software such as ESRI ArcView™, AutoCAD® Map 3D, Global Mapper, MapInfo™, etc.  Once high quality digital thermal and photographic ortho-rectified maps are created, they can be added as layers of other data sets, to existing or new CAD and GIS systems.  Digital data can also be post-processed in other ways, such as creating false color imagery to highlight areas of interest, adding temperature data and/or creating graphic reports (see Figure 6).



Qualitative v. Quantitative Evaluations

The imagery approach described above is qualitative.  It identifies and locates problems in steam systems based on their anomalous heat signatures.  This is low-hanging fruit with regard to return on investment.  Now, this method does not quantify the amount of heat loss.  In order to develop quantitative information, if desired, some additional work is needed in the form of additional field effort in the infrared data acquisition phase combined with heat transfer analysis of the steam distribution system.

To understand the quantitative approach, it is necessary to understand how heat moves and the factors affecting its transfer, as well as the physics involved in determining the infrared signature.  In order to know exactly what the radiated energy of any object is, the characteristics of the sensor, atmosphere and the target must be taken into consideration and one must know the transmission, emissivity and reflectivity of the target.  There are big differences in the emissive qualities of concrete, asphalt, grass, dirt, etc.  The ability to obtain quantitative measurements is built into a radiometric imaging system, so one must use a radiometric infrared camera to collect the imagery, and in a form that can be post-processed.

Heat energy moves by conduction, convection and radiation.  In order to make meaningful quantitative thermal calculations, the pipe’s or pipe’s content’s temperature, insulation properties and the complete thermal properties of all the materials in the ground (specifically heat capacity, thermal conductivity, and density) must all be known and made part of the calculation.  As-built drawings and the thermal properties are not always readily available, if available at all.  This generally means that estimates of the heat loss, implications of temperature values obtained, and quantitative evaluation of the pipe’s performance can only be developed as estimates.

Even though some large format thermal imaging systems are fully capable of accurate radiometric measurements and rapid frame-by-frame digital temperature data acquisition of every pixel of every IR image, the cost of quantitatively gathering measurements and using steady-state and transient heat transfer analysis calculations (typically done with FEA or finite element analysis), make quantitative measurement a more expensive step, than simply using the image data to make judgments based on experience of the person analyzing thermal data.  Most of the time, identifying leaks and excessive line heat loss is straightforward, but making calculations regarding insulation effectiveness and other qualities is an additional step that adds cost, which may add value, but also could offer a lower return on investment.  In other words, grab the low-hanging fruit first by identifying leaks, and if you have a known issue (or find one) requiring quantification, then post-process the thermal data.  If you expect to need quantification, it is wise to plan it ahead of time since it will slightly affect the methods used for IR image acquisition.

Ancillary Benefits

Safety is improved, asset reliability by condition monitoring can be achieved and wasted energy can be saved by aerial IR imaging, analysis and repairing the steam distribution system.  Creating a ‘thermal map’ of a given area has benefits far beyond that of just steam.  A thermal map helps asset managers in the analysis of many other types of systems, such as HTHW (high temperature hot water) lines, MTHW (medium temperature hot water) lines, LTHW (low temperature hot water) lines, CHWS (chilled water supply), CHWR (chilled water return), supply water mains, storm water drains, sewer lines and any other distribution piping.  Also, Electric power lines and substations can be surveyed to point maintenance personnel at the facility to electrical problems.

Drawing the entrained moisture in flat and low-sloped roofs on a CAD drawing with surgical precision provides a significant predictive maintenance benefit.  Roofs are an expensive and onerous asset to maintain.  Entrained moisture (see Figure 7) in the insulation and other roof substrates is indicative of leaks into the roof substrates, seam and flashing failures.


However unfortunate, ‘wholesale’ building heat loss surveys cannot be accomplished with a NADIR thermal survey, primarily because most building roofs are decoupled from the heat loss of the building, either with ventilation, with insulation or by being so reflective that they are immeasurable with IR sensors.  Oblique aerial or on-ground, right-angle infrared surveying of the walls will be necessary to accomplish building heat loss surveys.

Gregory R. Stockton is president of Stockton Infrared Thermographic Services, Inc. Based in Randleman, NC, the corporation operates six applications-specific divisions. Greg has been a practicing infrared thermographer since 1989. He is a Certified Infrared Thermographer with twenty-six years experience in the construction industry, specializing in maintenance and energy-related technologies. Mr. Stockton has published eleven technical papers on the subject of infrared thermography and written numerous articles about applications for infrared thermography in trade publications. He is a member of the Program Committee of SPIE (Society of Photo-Optical Instrumentation Engineers) Thermosense and Chairman of the Buildings & Infrastructures Session at the Defense and Security Symposium.

Eric Raymond Stockton of Stockton Infrared Thermographic Services, Inc., Silk Hope, NC for assistance in preparation of this paper in application of predictive maintenance applications issues.

Jack M. Kleinfeld, P.E. of Kleinfeld Technical Services, Inc., Bronx, NY for assistance in preparation of this paper in application of heat transfer analysis issues.

Alejandro Tache Leon of AITscan Division of Stockton Infrared Thermographic Services, Inc., Orlando, FL for assistance in preparation of this paper and in application of thermal mapping issues.

Upcoming Events

August 9 - August 11 2022

MaximoWorld 2022

View all Events
80% of newsletter subscribers report finding something used to improve their jobs on a regular basis.
Subscribers get exclusive content. Just released...MRO Best Practices Special Report - a $399 value!
Conducting Asset Criticality Assessment for Better Maintenance Strategy and Techniques

Conducting an asset criticality assessment (ACA) is the first step in maintaining the assets properly. This article addresses the best maintenance strategy for assets by using ACA techniques.

Harmonizing PMs

Maintenance reliability is, of course, an essential part of any successful business that wants to remain successful. It includes the three PMs: predictive, preventive and proactive maintenance.

How an Edge IoT Platform Increases Efficiency, Availability and Productivity

Within four years, more than 30 per cent of businesses and organizations will include edge computing in their cloud deployments to address bandwidth bottlenecks, reduce latency, and process data for decision support in real-time.

MaximoWorld 2022

The world's largest conference for IBM Maximo users, IBM Executives, IBM Maximo Partners and Services with Uptime Elements Reliability Framework and Asset Management System is being held Aug 8-11, 2022

6 Signs Your Maintenance Team Needs to Improve Its Safety Culture

When it comes to people and safety in industrial plants, maintenance teams are the ones who are most often in the line of fire and at risk for injury or death.

Making Asset Management Decisions: Caught Between the Push and the Pull

Most senior executives spend years climbing through the operational ranks. In the operational ranks, many transactional decisions are required each day.

Assume the Decision Maker Is Not Stupid to Make Your Communication More Powerful

Many make allowances for decision makers, saying some are “faking it until they make it.” However, this is the wrong default position to take when communicating with decision makers.

Ultrasound for Condition Monitoring and Acoustic Lubrication for Condition-Based Maintenance

With all the hype about acoustic lubrication instruments, you would think these instruments, once turned on, would do the job for you. Far from it!

Maintenance Costs as a Percent of Asset Replacement Value: A Useful Measure?

Someone recently asked for a benchmark for maintenance costs (MC) as a percent of asset replacement value (ARV) for chemical plants, or MC/ARV%.