From an asset management perspective, it is necessary to understand the root cause of plant failure in order establish effective condition monitoring and asset management strategies. AIG and other organizations have conducted considerable research into the reasons for plant failure. Not surprisingly, many plant failure studies into mechanical and electrical equipment failures reveal similar system failure root causes, which are indicated in Figure 3
and 4.

The data for Figure 3 has been taken from a number of industries of varying ages and capacity factors. In general, the data indicates that human intervention in the machine in the form of lubrication quality and contamination control is the primary factor in the longevity of mechanical plants. The data also indicates that lubrication analysis is the prime control method of determining mechanical plant condition, particularly in rotating mechanical plants.

Figure 3 - Primary Causes of Mechinical Equipment Failure

Figure 4 depicts the systems within electrical plants that have been the principle failure cause for those plants. It is interesting to note that mechanical systems within electrical plants are the prime failure areas. The obvious connotation from this data is that the complete suite of both mechanical and electrical testing and condition determination regimes must be applied to all plant types. The complimentary nature of the condition assessment techniques requires that the systems used to record and report on plant condition need to be fully integrated, and contain data, analysis and prognosis from disparate CM tools to give a complete description of the plant

Figure 4-Primary Causes of Electrical Plant Failure

With these failure modes in mind, to obtain an excellent rating from insurers the asset management and condition monitoring technologies that are required for a utility include:


. Online vibration spectral analysis of main plant including turbines, generators, feed pumps.
. Online vibration measurement and trips on auxiliary plant.
. Spectro chemical and Microscopic wear debris analysis of all main lube oil systems.
. Infrared thermography of all main plant including turbine casings, boilers, auxiliary plant bearings.
. Eddy current testing of condensers
. Time of flight ultrasonics (TOFD)
. Eddy current & remote field testing (EC & RFT)
. Remote visual inspection (RVI)
. Replication
. Bore oxide ultrasonics
. Mini creep testing
. X Ray analysis


. Dissolved gas analysis (DGA)
. Dissolved moisture
. Oil quality (acid, interfacial tension, dielectric strength, dielectric dissipation factor)
. Particle count
. Dissolved metals and sulphur
. Furans
. Dielectric loss angle
. Insulation resistance
. Dielectric dissipation factor
. Insulation recovery voltage
. Partial discharge
. Time reflectometry
. Radio frequency emission
. Transfer function

Risk Assessment Tools:

. HAZOPS - Hazard & Operability Studies
. QRA - Quantitative Risk Assessment
. WRAC - Workplace Risk Assessment and Control
. RCM-RA - Reliability Centred Maintenance Risk Assessment

It should be carefully noted however that the existence of these systems at a site is not the determining factor for a risk management engineer. The critical aspect is how these systems are utilized in the asset management planning cycle. All of the above systems require analysis and prognosis development by humans, and the qualifications and experience of the people conducting the testing and performing the analysis are of crucial importance to the insurance industry.

Tip from Ian Barnard, Author, Engineering Asset Management an Insurance Perspective

Upcoming Events

August 9 - August 11 2022

MaximoWorld 2022

View all Events
80% of newsletter subscribers report finding something used to improve their jobs on a regular basis.
Subscribers get exclusive content. Just released...MRO Best Practices Special Report - a $399 value!
 How To Achieve An Uptime Elements Black Belt

How To Achieve An Uptime Elements Black Belt

Do or do not – there is no try ~ Yoda

Are you one of those people who will not start a project until planning is close to perfect?

The Uptime Elements Black Belt program is designed


 Keep the Air Your Machine Breathes Clean and Dry

Keep the Air Your Machine Breathes Clean and Dry

It is important to stop airborne contaminants from entering tanks, drums, or machine reservoirs. The good news is that this is one of the easiest problems to address through high quality

Tip ...

 Optimizing Costs Through RCM-Based O&M

Optimizing Costs Through RCM-Based O&M

Today’s water and wastewater facilities must balance the demands of safety, environment and cost. With shrinking budgets, water and wastewater treatment facilities are asked to do more with

  • ...

How Complex Should Maintenance Procedures Be?

The level of complexity depends on several factors:

  • The complexity of the task. Tasks which have multiple steps that must be performed in specific sequence, or contain unusual operations, must be spelled out precisely.
  • What specific data is needed